Quilt Show Judging
Quality judging is much more than assigning ribbons and finding the most likeable quilt in a show. Good judging starts with an experienced, unbiased, competent and knowledgeable judge. It is essential to examine numerous details and specifics in a very short amount of judging time. Very few judges complain that they have too much time to judge. Usually it is a complaint of `More time...more time'.
Good judging begins with the quilt basics - design and workmanship.
Design is examined and sets the stage for the remainder of the critique. An excellent quilt begins with excellent design. Whether an original design or a published pattern, design is the framework for all choices made by the quilt maker. For the judge, it is essential to recognize period recreations, known styles, and current trends. It is important to know specific construction details for various typical styles such as Crazy Quilts, Baltimore Album, Hawaiian, etc. With the interest in period quilts, it is also helpful to know what is appropriate in design, construction, and fabric choices for the various eras of quilting. It is also expected that the judge be aware of current trends, styles, and fads.
Critique of workmanship is the other half of judging. It is essential to have good workmanship in ribboning quilts, but very few if any quilts are perfect. Many specific criteria are examined under workmanship: piecing, appliqué, quilting, sashing and borders, corners, binding, and finishing. Thorough judging examines scores of details in a very short time. Consistent good technique produces quality workmanship. It is important to recognize and comment on the quality of workmanship found in the judged quilt.
Good judging communicates design and workmanship specifics to the entrant. Because the goal of good judging is to educate and encourage quilters, it is essential to communicate and convey relevant information back to the quilt maker. Constant critical comments do not build up and encourage a quilt maker. It is a balance of positive and constructive comments that educate and encourage the quilt maker. Often, the quilt maker has a very good idea of where the flaws lie in the work, but many may have no idea how very well they have executed other facets of their work. Relevant comments may serve to educate the quilt maker on the positive qualities of the work.
It is essential to realize that when a quilt is judged, the judge holds countless hours and sometimes years of a quilter's life in their hands. Every entry is a work of love and time and is an offering of the quilter's talents to public scrutiny. A quality judge recognizes what she holds as the judging occurs and treats every quilt with respect.
Just as there are very few if any perfect quilts, no judge is perfect either. However, with quality judging there is an expectation of fair, knowledgeable, and unbiased judging.